IVORY🎹
I think the opening sequence of the film is very effective, I enjoy the fact that the diegetic sound of the piano is acting as non-diegetic sound as the main character is walking towards it. I also think it's clever that the playing piano shots are cut so that the spectator can't tell that the main actor isn't actually playing. The film has a clear use of the 3 act structure, and sound/the loss of it is very important in this. However, I think that in some moments the sound wasn't executed perfectly, for example in the park, the sound of teh plane flying overhead overpowers the sound of the actors talking. I also think that some of the dialogue, especially in the park scene, feels a bit clunky.
MON TOURNESOL🌻
I really like how this film uses cinematography to convey power, especially through the use of low angle, high angle, and pov shots at different moments, also the use of mirror shots to show reflection are very good. I also really like the colour grading- and how teh film starts of quite bright and warm, then gets quite white and plain, and then progressively gets warmer as the main character gets happier again. However, one criticism is that the background noise in the outdoor scene is quite loud and overpowering. But overall, I think this is a good film.
CALL☎️
I really like this film's use of expressionistic lighting, when the character is in a black background, with different coloured lights on his face. I also think that the use of chopping between different close ups is very effective in showing the character's reaction to the phone call. However, this film doesn't follow the 3 act structure, with there only being two acts (the nurse phoning him and his reaction), it could've been a good idea to add a final act where the character is going to the doctor, so the spectator can find out what's wrong with him, and if he'll get better.
TAKE ME BACK📸
I really like how this film uses a different camera to show what parts are memories, and what parts are current, like the memories from the past being grainy, and the present day being clear. I also think it's clever how the 3 act structure is moved around, and it's good that each act is labelled, so as to avoid confusion. I think the influence of verbatim theater clearly comes across, and is an interesting concept for a short film. My only criticism is that the Grandma's memory loss doesn't come across very clearly. Other than that, I like this film.